Today, we were lucky enough to have 16-year-old Shelby Miller from Portland, Mich., in the Channel 95.7 studio. Shelby is on this season's "American Idol" on Fox.

Because of the rules from "American Idol", Shelby is not allowed to sing.

So, we found it fitting for us to sing for her as an audition.

While Shelby was very polite and did not pick a favorite singer, we have a poll that you can take and choose who YOU would have as your American Idol: Amanda, Curtis or Intern Madge?