American Idol is known for finding stars, but most of the time it isn't the actual winner of the contest that ends up with an award winning career.  Often times it is 2nd place, or 3rd place that ends up with hit after hit (take Adam Lambert for instance... does anyone even remember the actual winner of that year?).

Well, Kidd Kraddick was a firm believer that Idol threw away it's top talent when the field was cut from 24 to 13.  So now you can help decide if, in fact, Tim Halperin should have won American Idol!

Now is your chance to weigh in on Kidd's contest.  First off here is the segment introducing Tim, laying down the rules, and going through the Tim's song choices:

And now for his competition's song "When a Man Loves a Woman" by Stefano:

And finally here is Tim's version of "When a Man Loves a Woman"...

You can vote on a specially made Facebook page made of the contest.