What Exactly is the Flavor Behind Michigan’s Blue Moon Ice Cream?

Since the beginning of time, people have been trying to solve one mystery... What exactly is the flavor of Blue Moon ice cream?

Blue Moon ice cream is more than just a sweet treat—it’s a vibrant, delicious mystery that proudly represents Michigan’s love for unique flavors. With its signature bright blue color and marshmallow-sweet taste, Blue Moon has long been a favorite in the Upper Midwest.

BELOW: Have you tried all of the food chains based in Michigan? ⬇️

While its origins are hotly debated, Michiganders know one thing for sure: this iconic flavor started right here in the Great Lakes State. Sure, Milwaukee might claim a stake, but Michigan holds the bragging rights, with strong ties to Plainwell and Ludington as its potential birthplace. Let’s be honest—our neighbors across Lake Michigan can’t compete with our knack for culinary creativity. The best they have to offer is cheese curds.

What makes Blue Moon so special? Much like the 11 herbs and spices at KFC, its exact recipe is a closely guarded secret. The distinct flavor has been described as a mix of citrusy raspberry and lemon, though some insist it’s closer to a fruity cereal milk. Most people agree, that almond extract is likely playing a big hand in the flavor since many store-bought versions warn of potential nut allergies. Homemade versions often include ingredients like vanilla pudding mix, heavy cream, egg yolks, and, of course, plenty of blue food coloring to achieve its electric hue.

The result is a flavor that feels both nostalgic and otherworldly—perfect for summertime scoops or a burst of childhood joy.

Interestingly, the taste and texture of Blue Moon can vary depending on where you buy it. Each ice cream parlor or brand seems to have its own interpretation, which only adds to its mystique. Whether it’s slightly tangy, sweeter than candy, or somewhere in between, every version of Blue Moon is a little piece of regional pride.

And let’s not forget—it’s a key component of Superman ice cream, another Michigan-born classic. So, next time you’re indulging in a cone of Blue Moon, know you’re tasting a delicious piece of Michigan history.